Safety Razors

What are the downsides of using a straight razor?

The main downsides of a straight razor: a learning curve of months, higher cut risk, stropping and honing, upfront cost and time. How it compares with a safety razor.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. The main downsides
  3. What about shavettes?
  4. Straight razor vs safety razor
  5. Who should still try one
  6. How to reduce the downsides

The short answer

The main downsides of a straight razor are a long learning curve (often a few months before shaves are consistently comfortable), a higher risk of cuts than with a safety razor, ongoing maintenance (stropping before every shave and periodic honing), a higher upfront cost for the razor and strop, and more time per shave. None of these stop people enjoying straight razors, but they’re worth knowing before you buy one.

The main downsides

A long learning curve

With a straight razor, you control everything: the angle, the pressure, the direction and the stretch of the skin. There’s no guard. Most people need weeks to get reasonable shaves and longer to get consistently good ones. One experienced forum member described inconsistent shaves with significant irritation for the first few months, with things only starting to come together at around four months. That’s one person’s experience, but it’s not unusual.

Higher risk of cuts

An open blade with no guard can cut more deeply than a safety razor. Most beginner cuts are small nicks, but a lapse in concentration can cause a more serious cut. Careful technique, a slow pace and avoiding distractions make a big difference, but the risk is inherently higher than with a guarded razor.

Ongoing maintenance: stropping and honing

A straight razor’s edge needs looking after:

  • Stropping on a leather strop before each shave realigns the edge. It’s quick once learned, but a slip can nick the strop.
  • Honing on stones every so often restores sharpness when stropping no longer does. Honing is a skill in itself. Many people send razors to a professional honer instead, which adds cost and time.

Upfront cost

Getting started means buying a shave-ready razor, a strop and eventually either hones or a honing service. A good-quality setup usually costs more than a safety razor and a supply of blades, though it can last a very long time.

Time

Even for experienced users, a straight razor shave usually takes longer than a safety razor or cartridge shave, especially with stropping included.

Tricky areas

The upper lip, chin and the area under the jaw are harder with a straight razor because of the curves and the need to change grip and hand. Many people take a while to master these spots or finish them with a safety razor.

Rust and storage

Many straight razors are carbon steel, which rusts if left wet. The blade needs to be dried carefully after each shave and stored somewhere dry. A folded straight razor also needs to be stored safely out of reach of children.

Travel

Straight razors generally can’t go in airline hand luggage and need to go in checked baggage. Check your airline’s rules.

What about shavettes?

A shavette is a straight-razor-style handle that takes disposable blades, usually half a DE blade or a purpose-made single edge blade. It removes the need for stropping and honing, which is why barbers use them.

But shavettes have downsides of their own:

  • The blades are thin and flexible, and many people find them harsher than a traditional straight razor.
  • The learning curve for angle and technique is just as long.
  • The cut risk is similar.

See what is the best single-edge razor blade? for blades that fit shavettes and Artist Club razors.

Straight razor vs safety razor

Straight razor Safety razor
Learning curve Months Usually a few weeks
Guard None Safety bar or comb
Maintenance Strop every shave, hone periodically Change blade every few shaves
Upfront cost Higher Lower
Running cost Very low after setup Low
Time per shave Longer Moderate

For most people, a safety razor gives a comparably close shave with far less effort. Our complete safety razor guide explains how they work.

Who should still try one

A straight razor is worth trying if you:

  • Enjoy learning a skill for its own sake
  • Have the patience for a few months of mixed results
  • Like the idea of a tool that can last a lifetime
  • Have time for a slower shave

How to reduce the downsides

  • Buy a shave-ready razor from a reputable seller, so you aren’t learning on a dull edge.
  • Get the strop and razor from the same place or ask for advice on matching them.
  • Use a professional honing service at first instead of learning to hone straight away.
  • Learn on easy areas like the cheeks and finish with a safety razor until you’re confident.
  • Keep a safety razor for busy mornings.
  • Shave when you’re not rushed and without distractions.

If you want to improve your technique on a safety razor first, finding the right blade angle covers skills that carry straight over to a straight razor.

The complete guide to safety razors

Safety Razors: The Complete Guide to Double Edge Shaving
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →