The short answer
Cut-throat razors are worth it if you enjoy the process of shaving, are willing to practise for several weeks, and will keep up the maintenance. They’re usually not worth it if you want the fastest, easiest shave possible.
A cut-throat (straight) razor can give a very close, controlled shave and can last for decades. In return it asks for time, patience and a little skill.
What you get
- A close, precise shave. With a sharp edge and good technique, a straight razor can shave very closely. The single exposed edge also gives excellent control for edging beards, sideburns and necklines.
- Longevity. A good traditional razor, cared for properly, can last a lifetime. Many vintage razors are still in use.
- Low ongoing costs. There are no cartridges or blades to keep buying for a traditional razor.
- Less waste. No disposable blades or plastic cartridges going in the bin.
- The ritual. Many people simply enjoy it: stropping, lathering, and taking time over the shave.
What it costs you
Money
The upfront cost is higher than a cartridge or safety razor. You’ll typically need:
- A traditional straight razor from a reputable maker, ideally shave ready
- A strop
- A brush and a good shaving soap or cream, if you don’t have them already
- Occasional honing, either from a honing service or on your own stones
Over several years, ongoing costs are low, but it takes a while for a traditional razor to pay for itself compared with cheaper options. A replaceable-blade razor (shavette) is far cheaper to start with; see shavette vs straight razor.
Time
A straight razor shave takes longer, especially while you’re learning. Add stropping before the shave and a minute of cleaning and drying afterwards. Many shavers find they speed up with experience, but it’s rarely as quick as a cartridge.
Learning curve and nicks
Expect a learning period of several weeks or more. Holding the right angle, using light pressure, and managing the tricky spots (under the nose, chin and jawline) takes practice. Small nicks are common at first. Most experienced shavers recommend starting slowly, on the cheeks, and finishing tricky areas with your usual razor until your confidence grows. Our straight razor tips for beginners has more.
Maintenance
A traditional razor needs stropping before most shaves, careful drying, oil if it’s carbon steel, and periodic honing. Our straight razor care and maintenance guide covers the full routine. Skipping maintenance is the most common reason people give up.
Practical limits
Straight razors are generally not allowed in carry-on luggage on flights, so travelling with one usually means checking a bag (see flying with a safety razor, which also covers straight razors). They also need careful storage away from children.
Who it’s worth it for
- People who enjoy wet shaving as a hobby or ritual
- People who like maintaining their own tools
- Those who want precise beard edging and don’t mind slower shaves
- Shavers looking for a long-lasting razor with little ongoing waste
Who probably shouldn’t bother
- Anyone who wants a shave done in a few minutes every morning
- People who won’t strop or keep the razor dry
- Anyone uncomfortable handling a very sharp, exposed edge
- Those with skin conditions or who are prone to bleeding easily; check with a doctor if you’re unsure whether wet shaving with an open blade is appropriate for you
For a broader comparison with everyday razors, see is it better to use a straight razor or a disposable razor?.
How to try it without overcommitting
- Start with a shavette if you mainly want to test the technique. It’s cheap and needs no strop or honing, though some people find disposable blades harsher.
- Buy a shave-ready traditional razor from a reputable maker or specialist retailer, and an inexpensive strop. A poor edge makes learning much harder, so this matters. Our guide to the best straight razors explains what to look for, and our guide to straight razor kits covers bundles.
- Consider a restored vintage razor from a reputable restorer, which can offer good value.
- Use a professional honing service at first, so you can focus on shaving technique before learning to sharpen.
Give it a few weeks of regular practice before deciding. Many people who stick with it past the first month or so end up keeping a straight razor for good.