The short answer
Both are excellent, widely recommended double edge blades. The difference is mostly one of degree:
- Astra Superior Platinum is smooth, forgiving and inexpensive, with medium-high sharpness. It’s the safer all-round choice, especially if you’re still refining your technique or have sensitive skin.
- Personna Platinum Chrome is generally considered sharper while still smooth. It suits coarser beards and shavers who find Astra a touch mild. It usually costs a little more.
If you’re not sure, start with Astra. If Astra tugs on your toughest areas, try Personna Platinum Chrome.
The two blades at a glance
| Astra Superior Platinum | Personna Platinum Chrome | |
|---|---|---|
| Typically made in | Russia | Israel |
| Packaging | Green | Red and white |
| Sharpness | Medium-high | High |
| Smoothness | Very smooth | Smooth |
| Forgiveness | High | Moderate |
| Typical longevity | Good | Good, varies by beard |
| Price | Low | Low to moderate |
Ratings reflect general shaver consensus, not lab measurements.
Astra Superior Platinum
Astra blades are produced in St. Petersburg, Russia, at a plant associated with Gillette. The Superior Platinum (green box) is the version most people mean when they say “Astra.” Shavers consistently describe it as smooth, comfortable and easy to get on with. It cuts most beards cleanly without feeling harsh, and many people get several shaves per blade. That reputation is why it’s so often the default recommendation for new DE shavers and for anyone who says “I don’t know what to buy next.”
Astra also makes a Superior Stainless (blue box), which some shavers find a little different in feel. This comparison focuses on the green Superior Platinum.
Personna Platinum Chrome
Personna is a long-established blade brand. The Platinum Chrome blade in red-and-white packaging is often called the “red Personna” or “Israeli Personna” by wet shavers. It has a strong reputation as a sharp, smooth blade, often mentioned in the same breath as Gillette Silver Blue as a step up from Astra that stops short of Feather-level keenness.
Which Personna are we talking about?
Personna sells more than one DE blade, which causes confusion:
- Personna Platinum Chrome (red): the blade compared here. Sharp and smooth.
- Personna Lab Blue / Med Prep: US-made blades originally associated with laboratory and medical prep use. Often described as smooth and durable, and generally a bit milder than the red Platinum Chrome.
When reading reviews, check which Personna the reviewer means.
Sharpness
Most shavers rank Personna Platinum Chrome sharper than Astra Superior Platinum. On coarse or dense stubble, Personna is more likely to cut cleanly in fewer passes. On fine hair the difference may be hard to notice. Neither is as sharp as Feather; see the sharpest razor blades you can buy.
Smoothness
Both are smooth. Astra has the edge for forgiveness: if your blade angle wanders or you press a little too hard, it’s less likely to nick you. Personna is smooth when used well, but its extra sharpness gives less margin for error. Coatings play a part in how both feel; our guide to razor blade coatings explains why.
Longevity
Reports vary widely with beard type and routine. Many shavers get three to five or more comfortable shaves from an Astra. Personna Platinum Chrome reports are similar for many people. Some find that, as with other sharp blades, it peaks early and then fades a little sooner. Change either one as soon as it starts to tug.
Price and availability
Both are inexpensive compared with cartridges, and both are cheapest in bulk boxes of 100. Astra is often among the lowest-cost quality blades available. Personna Platinum Chrome is usually a little more. Availability and pricing for both can vary by country and over time, so check current stock with your usual retailer.
Razor pairings
Blade and razor aggressiveness add together:
- Mild razor: Personna’s extra sharpness can help a gentle razor cut more efficiently.
- Medium razor: either works. Choose by beard and skin.
- Aggressive razor: Astra is often the more comfortable match, for example in an open comb safety razor.
If you’re choosing a razor too, see what is the best safety razor in 2026?.
Which should you choose?
Choose Astra Superior Platinum if:
- You’re new to DE shaving or still working on technique
- You have sensitive skin and a fine-to-medium beard
- You use an aggressive razor
- You want a very low cost per shave
Choose Personna Platinum Chrome if:
- Astra tugs on your chin, upper lip or neck
- You have a coarse or dense beard
- You use a mild or medium razor
- You want more sharpness without going all the way to Feather
How to compare them yourself
- Use the same razor, soap and prep for both.
- Give each blade three shaves before judging.
- Note sharpness, comfort and irritation after each shave.
- Try them back to back, a week each, rather than alternating daily.
Many sampler packs include both blades; see our guide to razor blade sampler packs. For other options, browse our full guide to the best double edge razor blades.